A Red Conference in Shanghai?

In a previous post, we looked at how British and Russian diplomats warned Beijing as early as January 1918 about Bolshevik plans to send provocateurs to China. The Foreign Ministry immediately alerted the governors of the Sino-Russian border provinces, as well as officials in regions with a sizeable foreign presence. However, the Soviet government was at the time more focused on the prospects of a revolution in Europe and on fending off a German offensive. Apart from a few anti-imperial promises directed unofficially to the Chinese embassy, the Bolsheviks had no active policy towards China in those early days.

Things had changed radically by the early months of 1919. The hoped-for German revolution culminated in a social democratic government and pitched battles between left- and right-wing militias. In Hungary, Bela Kun was poised on the brink of a coup. Communists in Poland and Ukraine faced an uncertain future as war broke out with Soviet Russia. Relations between communists in European Russia and those in the former imperial periphery had to be clarified. And in Paris, the Great Powers were assembling to redefine the world order. Even in the midst of the Russian Civil War, the international communist movement was in need of strategic direction and ideological guidance – with Lenin’s government providing the leadership.

1stkomintern
Delegates at the First Comintern Congress, 1919. Liu Zerong is the third man to the left of the flag. Source.

Accordingly, on 2-6 March 1919, a new, Third International was inaugurated in Moscow. While its focus was still chiefly on the communist parties in Western Europe and America, it included two Chinese delegates: Liu Zerong (alias Liu Shaozhou in Mandarin or Lau Siu-zao in Cantonese), whom we have already encountered as chairman of the Association of Chinese Diaspora in Russia, and fellow Association leader Zhang Yongkui. Both men represented the Chinese Socialist Workers’ Party, a group formed solely for the Congress; Liu’s short speech was not even included in the official minutes. Yet the revival of the International – and the participation of Chinese and Korean representatives – triggered another flurry of concern in Beijing, this time of a Bolshevik meeting in Shanghai.

據使團密告,俄過激黨將於廿二日在滬開會,莫斯科、西比利亞激黨首領均將與會。議題:一、今春在西比利亞擾亂。二、在中國、日本及歐美為種種之運動。三、聯合德國、波蘭過激派。並據報稱,此項消息確實可靠等語。務速設法探明禁阻,並電復。

According to a confidential message from the diplomatic corps, the Russian Reds will hold a meeting on the 22nd in Shanghai. Red leaders from Moscow and Siberia will all be present. Topics to be discussed: 1. To cause disorder in Siberia this spring; 2. Various activities in China, Japan, as well as Europe and America; 3. Alliances with the German and Polish Reds. Also, according to the reports, this information is accurate and reliable. This should be swiftly investigated and stopped; wire a reply.

Telegram to the Shanghai defence commissioner and envoy, 21 March 1919. Zhong-E Guanxi Shiliao: E Zhengbian yu Yiban Jiaoshe (2), Minguo Liunian zhi Banian, p. 112.

Such warnings capped off several months of what seemed like an escalating threat, first from provocateurs in Xinjiang and then among returning Chinese workers. This time, however, the threat had reached the Chinese heartland. On 26 March, Russian ambassador Kudashev informed the Foreign Ministry that the Reds were agitating in Beijing and Tianjin as well as Shanghai. Kudashev recommended more stringent measures, including the inspection of hotel registers. These were echoed by the Shanghai authorities.

maoinshanghai
Mao Zedong (seventh from left) in Shanghai in 1920, with members of the New Citizens’ Association (Xinmin xuehui). According to biographers, Mao’s first visit to Shanghai was in March 1919, to see off students going to France for the work-study movement. Source.

養日准貴部箇電,敬悉。經飭密查,俄過激黨確有派黨[員]分批來滬消息,其目的系在勾結中、日兩國人,一致行動,聞每批四人,已出發者兩批,尚未到滬。此事關系重大,亟應嚴行禁阻。現英捕房亦極為注意,昨派員來署接洽,商定協同辦理,所有現寓租界及華界之俄人,由捕房與警廳分別擔任調查,妥為防范。對於外來俄人,則查驗護照,詳細盤查,以免該黨混入。其著手辦法,凡大連、海參崴開滬輪船,由捕房設法檢查,滬寧車站由本署派憲兵會同警察駐守檢查,已分飭即日實行。

惟查中東鐵路為該黨乘車入內地必經之道。亟應知照該路各車站,遇有俄人購票時,預先查驗護照,並詳詢其來歷事由,如無護照,或形跡可疑,即不予售票,以阻其行。其他京奉、津浦、膠濟、京漢等路,亦應一律辦理,以昭周密。希迅轉交通部,分電各路局遵辦,仍乞電復為盼。再頃奉國務院巧電,俄激黨派華工回國運動圖擾,已飭軍警一體注意偵防矣。

Your Ministry’s telegram of the 21st received and read on the 22nd. An investigation was ordered; there has indeed been news that the Russian Reds are sending party members to Shanghai in groups, with the aim of colluding with Chinese and Japanese to act in concert. It is said that each group comprises four people and two groups have already set out, but not yet reached Shanghai. This matter is crucial and must be strictly prohibited. The British police station is also paying close attention now and sent a representative to my office yesterday to discuss this. It was agreed to deal with this jointly. All Russians now residing in the concessions and Chinese sector will be inspected by the [British] station and [Chinese] police department respectively, as a suitable precaution. Regarding Russians coming from outside, their passports will be checked and they will be closely questioned to prevent the Reds from slipping in. As for the method of implementation, all ships coming to Shanghai from Dalian and Vladivostok will be inspected by the station. My office will deploy military police which, together with police officers, will be stationed at and inspect the Shanghai-Nanjing train stations. We have instructed that this be implemented in the next few days.

However, when taking trains to the interior, the Reds must pass through the Chinese Eastern Railway. It is urgently necessary to inform the stations on that line that, when Russians purchase tickets, their passports should be inspected first and they should be closely questioned on their backgrounds and reasons for travel. If they have no passports or behave suspiciously, the tickets must not be sold, in order to prevent their journey. Other railways such as the Peking-Mukden, Tianjin-Pukou, Qingdao-Jinan and Peking-Hankow should also adopt such measures, in the interests of thoroughness. Please convey this quickly to the Communications Ministry, so that it may wire the railway bureaux to implement them. I would also be very grateful for a response. Also, I have just received the State Council’s telegram of the 18th on the Reds repatriating Chinese workers to cause disorder. Both the military and police have been instructed to pay attention to this, gather information and take precautions.

Telegram from Shanghai defence commissioner Lu Yongxiang, 1 April 1919. Ibid., pp. 133-134.
shanghaiyouthgrp
Members of the Chinese Socialist Youth League’s Foreign Languages Study Association in Shanghai, 1920. The League’s founder, Yu Xiusong, is in the middle of the back row. Source.

But was there indeed such a meeting in the works? The Bolsheviks certainly maintained an underground network in Harbin, but with the Civil War still raging it is doubtful that a systematic effort to send delegates to the Chinese heartland existed as early as March 1919. According to Ishikawa Yoshihiro, although a small number of radical socialists were active in Shanghai in 1918-1919, the first Bolshevik agents – A.S. Potapov and, most notably, G.N. Voitinskii – only arrived in China from late 1919 onwards. Neither did the Chinese Socialist Workers’ Party led by Liu and Zhang send representatives to China, despite its presence at the Comintern Congress. Finally, Liu Jianyi cites British records showing that four Russian provocateurs arrived in Shanghai in April 1919, but it seems that no formal conference occurred. Only two of the four became active propagandists, and then only after Voitinskii’s arrival.

In fact, it was Chinese intellectuals, not Russian provocateurs, whom the authorities had to fear. Li Dazhao, the “Father of Chinese Marxism”, had already written about the Victory of Bolshevism in November 1918; beginning in February 1919, Marxist ideas were being translated and disseminated in the Beijing newspaper Chenbao. The ongoing work-study movement, of which Shanghai was a centre, also became a seedbed for future Chinese communists. This nascent interest in Marxism would soar after the May 4th movement, and Potapov and Voitinskii would find an audience already receptive to Bolshevik ideas.

One thought on “A Red Conference in Shanghai?

  1. Pingback: A Mission to Moscow? – Shots Across the Amur 黑龍江對岸的槍聲

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s